{ Comments on this entry are closed }
{ Comments on this entry are closed }
{ Comments on this entry are closed }
By Linda E. (Pa)
This assessment is from: Eclipse (The Twilight Saga, 3rd Novel (paperback)
To preface this, I’ll say up front that I loathe adore triangles. They’re trite plot devices which are hardly ever executed well, and that’s just 1 with the large problems with Eclipse. It’s a love triangle that, according to the author, was developed for Bella to make a choice. Truly? Was there any shred of doubt more than what alternative she was going to go with?
Regretably for Eclipse, about three quarters with the book involved pitting Edward and Jacob against each other in a fight more than who Bella loves much more (and again, actually?). Positive, it is fantastic to become loved, but in this illustration it just makes everybody look bad. Jacob comes off as too sexually forceful, Edward looks like a lump on a log reciting the same “if it really is great for Bella, it really is great for me” line, and Bella looks a lot more selfish and whiny than usual. Sure, Bella was whiny and annoying way before Eclipse, but she puts on a grand display here and it makes one long for a point of view change. Anyone. Jessica’s point of view would most likely be preferable.
The rest with the book is about many deaths in Seattle that, of course, suggest Bella is in danger, which, naturally, means Edward has to act like a psycho boyfriend intent on protecting her from herself. Early on on he attempts to keep her house bound by ripping the sprkplug out of her car, and while I imagined that was a little alarmist and creepy he himself continuously after that. No wonder Bella kept grumbling and sighing each time he kept swooping in to tell her where not to go and precisely why. Then there’s the bridal issue — he expects to, she doesn’t (it’s embarrassing, you see…far much more than having to tell one’s family you intend to grow to be a vampire in the near future because marriage is so much a lot more shocking) — but it really is not like Bella has a say within the day that’s supposed to be hers. She honestly doesn’t. Perhaps these two should just go have a fling and a Date Night In Orange County? It reminded me slightly of an understanding than a celebration using the amount of moaning and wincing Bella does regarding the impending nuptials.
What annoyed me more, besides the rickety plot, the endless comparisons to To Kill A Mocking Bird (the novelist researched literature in university, I get it. many of us university educated individuals did and I still do not see the require for comparisons to Heath and Cathy), and also the annoying adore triangle, was how self-deprecating Bella was. How she continuously went through the book saying how not worth she was of every person, how responsible she was of almost everything, how clumsy, ridiculous, selfish (that 1 I actually don’t argue with), immoral, weak, helpless, pathetic, and frighteningly ordinary she is. Certain, it’s hard to have immortal, strong, mostly male friends, but as a woman I’d like to see Bella shed that “oh well, I’m just just a little vulnerable girl, woe is me, I’ll just sit inside the corner and die now” attitude without having to turn out to be a vampire. At every turn in Eclipse Bella depicts herself harshly, as well as the storyline does nothing to spin that around. She’s the tramp that needs to have sex outside of marriage (which is as well immoral for virtuous Edward), she’s the 1 that’s too weak to do anything other than be babysat, and for the most part the adventure agrees with her. The men (using the exception of potentially Alice) are the selfless heroes by the end, and the women are selfish (Bella), shallow (Rosalie), and bitter (Leah). Where have the strong female heroines absent?
{ Comments on this entry are closed }
{ Comments on this entry are closed }
